Hi jamvan,
i agree with Entan post previously,
please deliver more detail regarding this issue, at one part (sorry) i assumed that previously the issue was not there, then some process started, that makes the issue appear?
if so, please help to remember what is the last process before the issue appeared.
based on http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc850696.aspx article,
-
During the indexing process, the system stores the ACE of each user who was added to a SharePoint group instead of the ACE of the SharePoint group itself. This process supports approximately
1000 users per access control list (ACL), after which the "Parameter is incorrect" error causes crawling to fail.
if it is correct that it is because the ACL for users are exceeded, then please reduce the users or you may create a new group and move the users to the new group.